The Version That Stayed
Evaluation and Summary
This episode of Creepy presents three separate horror fiction stories. "The Version That Stayed," written by JQ Leonard and narrated by Jimmy Ferrer, appears to be the lead story, though the show notes provide no plot details. "The Cries of Long Dead Beasts," written by Juan Cardenas and narrated by Alicia Atkins, is the second piece—again, no synopsis is given. The final story, "Scratch," is written by Shaun Jex with no narrator credited in the notes, suggesting it may be read by the writer or another performer. The episode runs 1 hour 29 minutes total across these three stories. The show notes offer no information about plot, themes, tone, or what listeners should expect from any of the three pieces. No guest interviews, commentary, or framing context is provided. The episode is part of the Creepy podcast series, which appears to focus on horror fiction anthology content. The show is supported through Patreon and hosted on Acast.
Verdict: Insufficient source material prevents meaningful evaluation; the show notes contain only titles and credits with zero plot or content description, forcing a middle-ground rating.
Fiction rubric
-
Writing n/a
No plot details, dialogue samples, or writing descriptions provided in source material to evaluate script quality or distinctiveness.
-
Performance and production n/a
No information about acting quality, voice work, sound design, or production values in the available show notes.
-
Plot momentum n/a
No plot summaries or story descriptions available to assess whether narratives pull listeners forward or maintain engagement.
-
Substance n/a
Cannot evaluate content density without knowing what the three stories actually contain or explore thematically.
-
Delivers on its title 3/5 50%
Episode title "The Version That Stayed" appears to reference the lead story, suggesting the episode delivers on basic anthology format expectations, though the cryptic title gives little indication of actual content.
-
Value for time 3/5 50%
At 89 minutes across three stories, the pacing seems reasonable for a horror anthology, but without knowing story lengths or content, cannot assess whether time is well-spent.
Worth it if you're a regular Creepy podcast listener already familiar with the show's style and quality standards.
Based on the episode description. AI-generated; it can be wrong.
Show notes
More from Creepy
Creepy Day 9 is a 32-minute horror fiction podcast episode featuring two short stories written by D.H. Parish and narrated by Owen McCuen. The episode opens with "Witch's Lake" at the 2:02 mark, a story that appears to involve supernatural or eerie elements centered around a lake location with witch-related themes.…
Worth it if you enjoy short-form horror fiction anthologies and trust the Creepy podcast's track record for atmospheric storytelling.
Creepy's Day 8 episode presents two short horror fiction pieces. 'Spring Creek,' written by Cyndi Gradel and narrated by Megan McDuffee, opens the episode at 1:40 and involves a story with a child death content warning—suggesting a dark narrative centered on loss or tragedy in a rural setting. 'The Scarecrow of Black…
Worth it if you enjoy short-form horror fiction and trust the Creepy podcast's track record for quality narration and atmospheric storytelling.
This episode of Creepy presents two horror stories back-to-back. The first story, "Five-String Guitar" (1:28–26:02), is a creepypasta written by JrvUnleashed and available under Creative Commons licensing. The second story, "Supermarket Swamp Monster" (26:02–end), was written by Robert Lemons and narrated by Cole…
Worth it if you enjoy straightforward creepypasta narration and don't require host commentary, thematic framing, or production flourishes.
Day 6 of the Creepy podcast presents two short horror fiction pieces. 'Earworm,' written by No One of Consequence and narrated by Nate DuFort, begins at the 1:18 mark and presumably explores a horror concept related to an earworm—either a catchy song that won't leave your head or a parasitic creature. The second…
Worth it if you enjoy short horror fiction and trust the Creepy podcast's track record, but the vague show notes offer little reason to prioritize this episode.
Day 5 of the Creepy podcast presents two horror stories written by Greg Patrick and narrated by Jimmy Ferrer. 'The Chimney Goes Down' begins at the 3:36 mark, while 'The Shattered Funhouse Mirror' starts at 25:55, suggesting roughly equal time allocation between the two narratives across the 71-minute runtime. The…
Worth it if you're already invested in the Creepy podcast's serialized format and enjoy short horror fiction with professional narration.
This is Day 4 of the "Creepy" podcast anthology series, featuring two short horror stories. The first story, "We Meet Again," is written by Toni Nicolino and narrated by Danielle Hewitt. It runs from 1:23 to 11:32 (approximately 10 minutes) and carries a content warning for child death, suggesting it deals with dark…
Worth it if you're already a fan of the Creepy anthology series or enjoy short horror fiction with atmospheric narration, but the lack of plot details makes it hard to recommend to newcomers.