Practical Magic
Evaluation and Summary
What Went Wrong examines the 1998 film 'Practical Magic,' which arrived with an impressive cast (Sandra Bullock, Nicole Kidman) but flopped at the box office and with critics—a particularly painful outcome for director Griffin Dunne, who invested personal demons into the project. Hosts Chris and Lizzie investigate the film's journey from theatrical failure to home video cult success. The episode promises to cover how the lead actresses became attached to the project, an anecdote involving Barbra Streisand being fooled by the film, production design details (the sets), and a bizarre incident involving an actual witch attempting to sabotage the movie. The episode runs 82 minutes and concludes with a teaser for a subscriber-only sequel review of 'Practical Magic 2' (releasing Friday). The show notes suggest a narrative arc: initial failure → behind-the-scenes discovery → eventual redemption through home video and cultural reassessment.
Verdict: A well-structured deep dive into a cult film's redemption arc with promising behind-the-scenes access, though the actual execution and pacing remain unverified from show notes alone.
TV & Film rubric
-
Critical insight 3/5 20%
Show notes promise analysis of why the film failed theatrically and succeeded on home video, suggesting thematic exploration beyond plot recap, though depth cannot be verified from description alone.
-
Behind-the-scenes knowledge 4/5 20%
Multiple behind-the-scenes elements promised: casting stories (Bullock/Kidman), production design details, director's personal investment, and anecdotes (Streisand, the witch incident) suggest substantive insider access.
-
Entertainment 3/5 15%
The witch sabotage anecdote and Streisand story suggest entertaining moments, though overall liveliness cannot be assessed from notes alone.
-
Substance 3/5 15%
Multiple distinct topics (casting, production design, director's vision, cultural reception, bizarre incidents) indicate solid content structure, though 82 minutes for these topics could contain padding.
-
Delivers on its title 5/5 15%
Title 'Practical Magic' directly addresses the film; show notes comprehensively cover what went wrong (failure) and how it recovered, fully delivering on the premise.
-
Value for time 3/5 15%
82 minutes for a single film's behind-the-scenes story is substantial; without hearing the episode, pacing cannot be confirmed, but the variety of topics suggests reasonable structure.
Worth it if you're a 'Practical Magic' fan, interested in how films find second lives, or enjoy detailed production stories and Hollywood anecdotes.
Based on the episode description. AI-generated; it can be wrong.
Show notes
More from WHAT WENT WRONG
This is a rebroadcast episode of 'What Went Wrong' featuring James McAvoy discussing his directorial debut, 'California Schemin'.' The film tells the true story of two young Scottish rappers who reinvent themselves as Americans to escape ridicule and find success in the music industry. McAvoy joins hosts Chris and…
Worth it if you're interested in James McAvoy's directorial approach, the film 'California Schemin',' or want insider perspective on first-time directing from an established actor.
In this episode of 'What Went Wrong,' hosts Chris and Lizzie examine James Wan and Leigh Whannell's 2004 horror breakthrough 'Saw,' exploring how a low-budget indie project became an unexpected franchise juggernaut. The episode frames the film's creation as a case study in creative compromise and unintended success.…
Worth it if you're interested in how creative constraints and commercial success intersect, enjoy casual film discussion, or want to understand the origins of the 'Saw' franchise beyond the films themselves.
This episode of 'What Went Wrong' examines the life and death of Hollywood actress Lana Turner, focusing on her relationship with mobster Johnny Stompanato and the homicide that resulted from it. Host Lizzie is joined by guests Desi and Rachel from the podcast 'Hollywood Crime Scene' to explore Turner's rise from…
Worth it if you're interested in Old Hollywood scandals, true crime stories, or the darker side of celebrity culture in the mid-20th century.
In this episode of 'What Went Wrong,' hosts Chris and Lizzie examine Brian De Palma's 1976 adaptation of Stephen King's 'Carrie,' marking the film's 50th anniversary. The episode explores the production history and challenges behind bringing King's debut novel to the screen. Key topics include why the novel initially…
Worth it if you're interested in classic horror filmmaking, Stephen King adaptations, or Brian De Palma's directorial approach rather than thematic film analysis.
In this episode of "What Went Wrong," hosts Chris and Lizzie examine Paul W.S. Anderson's 2002 Resident Evil film, exploring how a movie widely regarded as flawed became a commercial success that revitalized Anderson's career, strengthened his relationship with Milla Jovovich (whom he later married), and boosted…
Worth it if you're interested in film adaptation failures, video game movies, or the personal drama behind Hollywood productions.
What Went Wrong's 'Witches! A Primer' is a 49-minute survey of witches across folklore, literature, and entertainment, hosted by Chris and Lizzie. The episode traces the evolution of witch depictions from Shakespeare's 'Macbeth' through classic film ('The Wizard of Oz'), contemporary media ('Weapons'), and into modern…
Worth it if you want a casual, accessible overview of witch tropes in entertainment timed for Halloween season, but not if you're seeking rigorous analysis or surprising cultural criticism.