Top 25 PS5 Games of ALL TIME - Kinda Funny Gamescast
Evaluation and Summary
This Kinda Funny Gamescast episode promises to rank the top 25 PS5 games of all time, a compelling premise for PlayStation enthusiasts. However, the show notes reveal a significant disconnect: the actual topic covered is labeled 'Shit List,' which begins at the 00:04:50 mark and runs until 00:30:30 when ads begin. The show notes don't clarify whether 'Shit List' refers to the promised top 25 PS5 games ranking or something entirely different. This ambiguity is problematic. If 'Shit List' is their term for ranking games, the episode would cover approximately 26 minutes of actual content discussing PlayStation 5 titles, which seems insufficient for thoroughly evaluating 25 games. That would allow roughly one minute per game—barely enough for meaningful discussion of each title's merits, gameplay, story, or cultural impact. The episode structure shows minimal content relative to its one-hour-two-minute runtime, with ads consuming a notable portion. Without additional details about guest appearances, specific games discussed, or the hosts' selection criteria, it's difficult to assess whether this delivers substantive gaming analysis or quick, surface-level takes. The title's promise of 'all time' rankings is also questionable given the PS5's relatively recent release (2020), limiting the library of games that could genuinely be considered 'all time' classics. Listeners expecting an in-depth, well-reasoned countdown of the PS5's best games may be disappointed by what appears to be a brief segment padded with advertising. The episode could work as casual gaming banter among friends, but it doesn't seem positioned as a comprehensive critical analysis. The Proton VPN sponsorship is standard for podcasts and doesn't detract from content quality, though it does occupy valuable real estate in the show notes.
Why this score: Limited content duration for the ambitious premise, unclear topic labeling, and insufficient time to meaningfully discuss 25 games make this feel rushed and potentially superficial.
Worth it if you enjoy casual gaming chat and quick takes on PS5 titles, but not if you want thorough critical analysis of PlayStation's best games.
Content flags
- Ad-heavy Show notes indicate ads begin at 30:30 in a 62-minute episode, suggesting significant ad load relative to actual content
Based on the episode description. AI-generated; it can be wrong.
Show notes
More from Kinda Funny Gamescast: Video Game Podcast
The Kinda Funny Gamescast episode centers on a hands-on preview of Phantom Blade Zero, an action game that appears to be the main topic of discussion. The hosts played the game and share their impressions, starting at the 5:45 mark and running until an ad break at 22:37—giving roughly 17 minutes of dedicated coverage.…
Worth it if you're a Phantom Blade Zero fan eager for early hands-on impressions and don't mind a longer podcast with mixed gaming news.
This Kinda Funny Gamescast episode focuses on The Witcher franchise, with the title promising discussion of what fans want from The Witcher 4. The episode opens with Witcher-related news, including coverage of The Witcher 3 Remastered's PS5 fixes and a mention of reporting from Elijah Gonzalez at Polygon. The hosts…
Worth it if you're a dedicated Kinda Funny listener who enjoys their hosts' personalities and casual Witcher chat, but not if you specifically want focused discussion about The Witcher 4.
Kinda Funny Gamescast dedicates this 70-minute episode to reviewing Gears of War E-Day, a prequel to the long-running Gears franchise launching October 8, 2026. The show follows a structured format where hosts Roger, Parris, Mike, and Andy each provide their individual scores and thoughts on the game before opening to…
Worth it if you're a Gears of War fan seeking multiple host perspectives before purchasing E-Day, or a Kinda Funny regular who enjoys their chemistry.
The episode title promises a 'Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time Hypecast,' suggesting deep discussion of Nintendo's classic 1998 game. However, the show notes provided contain no actual episode content—only sponsor information for Factor Meals and Alienware, plus a brief mention of an unrelated game called 'Forever…
Worth it if you're a Kinda Funny regular who enjoys the hosts' banter regardless of topic, but the show notes provide zero evidence this delivers on its Ocarina of Time premise.
This episode of Kinda Funny Gamescast is advertised as a Star Wars: Galactic Racer review, though the provided show notes offer virtually no detail about the actual content covered. The episode runs 1 hour and 26 minutes, suggesting a substantial discussion, but the source material provides only a VPN sponsor read and…
Worth it if you're a Kinda Funny Gamescast subscriber who trusts the hosts' gaming opinions, but the lack of detailed show notes makes it a blind purchase.
The Kinda Funny Gamescast dedicates this 54-minute episode to reviewing Gears of War E-Day, a prequel entry in the long-running third-person shooter franchise. The episode opens with approximately 5 minutes of introductory material before diving into the main review discussion at the 5:15 mark. The hosts spend a…
Worth it if you're a Gears of War fan considering E-Day or interested in detailed control scheme analysis for the franchise.