We Ranked Every Taylor Swift Deluxe Song Worst to Best

Evolution of a Snake presents a ranked list of Taylor Swift's deluxe edition tracks, prompted by Billboard's own ranking of the same material. The episode focuses on the four new deluxe tracks added with "Showgirl: The Encore" and positions them within the broader category of Swift songs that exist outside standard album releases, vault tracks, and one-off singles. The hosts frame this as offering "the Swiftie perspective" in contrast to Billboard's approach, suggesting they're bringing fan insight and enthusiasm to the ranking exercise. The episode promises a retrospective walk through Swift's deluxe catalog while evaluating where the new songs fit in the hierarchy. At 1 hour 19 minutes, the format appears to be a straightforward ranking discussion, likely with commentary on each track's merits, fan reception, and how the new additions compare to previously released deluxe songs. The show notes indicate this is fan-driven content rather than featuring artist interviews or insider access, positioning it squarely within the enthusiast podcast space.

Verdict: A straightforward fan ranking that delivers its title promise but offers limited musical insight, no access, and questionable pacing for its length—solid for dedicated Swifties seeking peer opinions but thin on substance for general listeners.

Music rubric

• Musical insight n/a

  Source material provides no detail about musical analysis, production, songwriting craft, or how the songs work—only that they're being ranked

• Access and stories 1/5 25%

  No indication of artist interviews, insider perspectives, or original stories; purely fan-driven ranking commentary

• Discovery 3/5 19%

  Listeners will encounter four new deluxe tracks and revisit the existing deluxe catalog, providing some exposure to material that may be unfamiliar to casual fans

• Substance 2/5 19%

  A ranking exercise with commentary is inherently thin on substance; without evidence of deep analysis or storytelling, this appears to be primarily a list with opinions rather than dense content

• Delivers on its title 5/5 19%

  Title promises a ranking of deluxe songs worst to best, and the description confirms exactly that with the four new tracks included

• Value for time 2/5 19%

  79 minutes for a ranked list of songs suggests potential padding; unclear if the pacing justifies the length without evidence of substantial discussion per track

How we score Music

Worth it if you're a Taylor Swift fan curious about how the new deluxe tracks stack up against the existing catalog and want to hear fellow fans' takes on the ranking.

Based on the episode description. AI-generated; it can be wrong.