Broadway's My Beat: The Robert Turk Murder Case (EP5078)
Evaluation and Summary
This episode of The Great Detectives of Old Time Radio presents "Broadway's My Beat: The Robert Turk Murder Case," a classic detective drama originally broadcast on October 18, 1952. The episode follows Detective Danny Clover as he investigates a bizarre murder in a Manhattan apartment. The case begins with what appears to be a suicide—a dead man surrounded by occult symbols in a woman's apartment—but quickly evolves into something far more complex. A woman barely survives the night, and as Clover digs deeper, he uncovers a series of deaths stretching back years, suggesting a pattern rather than isolated incidents. The investigation takes a supernatural turn when Clover encounters a mysterious woman who claims to possess the power to determine who lives and who dies, adding an occult dimension to what seemed like a straightforward homicide. The episode features a strong cast including Larry Thor as Detective Clover, Charles Calvert as Sgt. Tartaglia, and Jack Kruschen as Sgt. Muggavan, with supporting performances from Sammy Hill, Lee Millar, Truda Marson, and Lou Merrill. The episode was written by Morton Fine and David Friedkin, directed by Elliott Lewis, and features an original score by Alexander Courage. At 39 minutes, it represents a complete dramatic arc from the discovery of the body through investigation and resolution. The show is presented as part of a daily series dedicated to preserving and celebrating detective dramas from radio's golden age, with production values and talent that reflect the high standards of 1950s Hollywood radio drama.
Verdict: A well-crafted vintage mystery drama with strong talent and an intriguing supernatural premise that should satisfy fans of classic radio detective fiction.
Arts rubric
-
Insight into the work n/a
No discussion or analysis of the episode's craft, writing, or themes is provided in the show notes.
-
Expertise and access 5/5 25%
Episode features accomplished 1950s radio professionals: Elliott Lewis (renowned director), Morton Fine and David Friedkin (accomplished writers), and Alexander Courage (composer), plus skilled character actors.
-
Sparks curiosity 4/5 19%
The premise—occult symbols, a mysterious woman with life-or-death powers, and a series of connected deaths—is intriguing and suggests a compelling mystery.
-
Substance 3/5 19%
A full 39-minute drama with multiple plot threads (initial murder, survivor, series of deaths, supernatural element) suggests substantive content, though show notes don't detail pacing or filler.
-
Delivers on its title 5/5 19%
Title promises a detective case (Robert Turk Murder Case) and delivers exactly that: a murder investigation with Detective Clover as the central figure.
-
Value for time 3/5 19%
39 minutes is standard for a complete radio drama episode; without hearing it, unclear if pacing is tight or if there are slow stretches, so middle rating is appropriate.
Worth it if you enjoy classic 1950s radio drama, detective mysteries with occult elements, or want to experience well-produced entertainment from radio's golden age.
Based on the episode description. AI-generated; it can be wrong.
Show notes
More from The Great Detectives of Old Time Radio| Daily Mystery Dramas
This episode of The Great Detectives of Old Time Radio presents "The Big Story: A Search That Saved a Life," a dramatic mystery broadcast originally aired on February 10, 1954. The episode follows reporters Virginia Marmaduke and Joe Kordek as they investigate a deeply personal case that begins in a Chicago courtroom.…
Worth it if you enjoy Golden Age radio dramas with high emotional stakes, investigative journalism narratives, or vintage broadcast entertainment from the 1950s.