The Shadow - "Murder by Rescue" (Old Time Radio)
Evaluation and Summary
This is a restored broadcast of "Murder by Rescue," a 1938 episode of The Shadow radio drama from the Mutual Broadcasting System's Blue Coal-sponsored run. The episode stars Bill Johnstone as The Shadow (Lamont Cranston) and Agnes Moorehead as his companion Margot Lane. The plot centers on wealthy heir Warren Mitchell, who becomes entangled in a criminal scheme involving three key elements: a phonograph record, hypnosis, and a staged roadside rescue. The mechanics of the plot suggest a con or murder plot using these elements in combination—the record likely contains hypnotic suggestions, and the "rescue" appears to be a setup to manipulate or endanger Mitchell. Lamont Cranston and Margot Lane are drawn into the danger as they investigate. The episode is presented with modern production touches: a newly recorded contextual introduction by Victor Sterling (lasting about 1 minute), the original 29-minute broadcast itself, and a closing announcement. The audio has been cleaned and mastered to improve consistency and listenability compared to the original 1938 recording. This is part of an ongoing archival project to restore and present classic Old Time Radio content, with support available through Patreon and Spreaker.
Verdict: A competently restored classic radio episode with an intriguing premise and recognizable talent, but limited source material prevents confident assessment of writing, performance, or plot execution.
Fiction rubric
-
Writing n/a
No transcript or detailed plot description provided; cannot assess dialogue quality or script construction.
-
Performance and production 3/5 31%
Original 1938 broadcast with period-appropriate acting; modern mastering improves audio consistency but cannot elevate inherent limitations of 86-year-old source material.
-
Plot momentum n/a
Plot outline (hypnosis, phonograph record, staged rescue) suggests intrigue, but episode content itself is not described enough to judge pacing or narrative drive.
-
Substance 3/5 23%
A complete 29-minute mystery episode with setup, investigation, and resolution; solid content for the format, though show notes don't detail depth or complexity.
-
Delivers on its title 4/5 23%
Title promises a murder mystery involving rescue; plot description confirms a rescue scheme tied to potential murder, directly matching the premise.
-
Value for time 3/5 23%
31 minutes total (29 minutes of content plus intro/outro) is standard for the format; no evidence of padding, but also no indication of exceptional tightness.
Worth it if you enjoy Golden Age radio drama, appreciate historical audio restoration, or want to experience Bill Johnstone and Agnes Moorehead in a vintage mystery.
Based on the episode description. AI-generated; it can be wrong.
Show notes
More from The Shadow | Old Time Radio
This is a preserved broadcast of "The Shadow," a classic old-time radio mystery series from January 4, 1948. The episode, titled "The Chill of Death," follows Lamont Cranston (played by Bret Morrison) and his companion Margo Lane (Grace Matthews) as they investigate a sinister pattern of deaths among maids employed by…
Worth it if you enjoy classic old-time radio mysteries, appreciate the Shadow series, or want to experience well-preserved broadcasts from radio's golden age.
This is a restored broadcast of "Preview of Terror," a 1949 episode of The Shadow radio drama series. The episode, written by Frank Kane and originally aired June 5, 1949, follows Lamont Cranston and his companion Margo Lane as they're caught in a storm and forced to seek shelter at an isolated old house. There they…
Worth it if you enjoy vintage radio drama, The Shadow series, or 1940s entertainment history with restored audio quality.
The Shadow - "The Tomb of Terror" is a restored broadcast from June 1938 featuring Orson Welles-era production values and Margot Stevenson as Margot Lane. The episode centers on a classic mystery setup: the City Museum prepares to display an ancient Egyptian tomb when a series of deaths occur, seemingly confirming an…
Worth it if you enjoy classic radio drama, 1938-era entertainment, or atmospheric mystery stories with supernatural elements.