Lizzie Borden: Part 2 | My Life of Crime with Erin Moriarty
Evaluation and Summary
In Part 2 of this 48 Hours/My Life of Crime crossover episode, correspondent Erin Moriarty examines the trial of Lizzie Borden, the 32-year-old woman accused of murdering her father and stepmother with an ax in 1892. The episode opens with Moriarty spending a night at the Lizzie Borden Bed and Breakfast/Museum, using the atmospheric setting to frame the enduring mystery of whether Lizzie actually committed the crimes. The core of the episode focuses on the historical trial itself, drawing heavily from author Cara Robertson's book about Lizzie's case, which is constructed directly from court records. Moriarty and Robertson examine the prosecution's case against Lizzie, which includes circumstantial evidence that she was home at the time of the murders, that she burned a dress (potentially to destroy evidence), and that she may have had financial motive. The episode promises to reveal the jury's verdict after 90 minutes of deliberation, framed as surprising. The narrative explores the historical justice system of the late 19th century and the broader question of why a woman of wealth and privilege would commit such brutal murders. The episode is positioned as an "unusual narrative" that blends true crime investigation with historical analysis and atmospheric storytelling.
Verdict: A competent historical true crime episode that delivers on its promise of examining the Lizzie Borden trial through court records and a historian's lens, with solid research and respectful framing, though the brief runtime and lack of evidence of original reporting limit its depth.
True Crime rubric
-
Research depth 3/5 20%
Episode draws from court records via author Cara Robertson's book, providing historical primary sources, though the show notes don't indicate original reporting or new interviews beyond Robertson.
-
Storytelling 3/5 20%
Atmospheric framing device (spending night at the B&B/museum) adds narrative interest, but show notes suggest a fairly straightforward trial recap without detail on pacing or structural craft.
-
Respect for victims 3/5 15%
Focuses on the legal mystery and historical context rather than sensationalizing the murders; no evidence of exploitation, though limited detail on victim-centered approach.
-
Substance 3/5 15%
Covers prosecution's case, evidence (dress burning, motive, presence at scene), and historical justice system context; 22 minutes is brief for a trial recap, suggesting some compression.
-
Delivers on its title 4/5 15%
Title promises Lizzie Borden trial coverage and delivers exactly that; the 'My Life of Crime' framing is met, though the 'unusual narrative' claim relies on the B&B framing device.
-
Value for time 3/5 15%
22 minutes is tight for a complex historical trial; likely reasonably paced but may feel rushed given the amount of material (prosecution case, motive, verdict reveal).
Worth it if you're interested in historical true crime, the Lizzie Borden case specifically, or how 19th-century justice systems handled high-profile murder trials.
Based on the episode description. AI-generated; it can be wrong.
Show notes
More from 48 Hours
This 48 Hours episode examines the case of Caleb Flynn, a music pastor who murdered his wife after a 13-year gap between his public appearance on American Idol—where he professed deep love for her—and his eventual conviction and life sentence. The episode is guided by correspondent Anne-Marie Green and investigator…
Worth it if you enjoy straightforward true crime reconstruction with a dramatic irony hook and don't require deep-dive reporting or exclusive access.
48 Hours examines the 2010 death of Sylvie Cachay, a promising fashion designer found dead in a bathtub at the Soho House hotel in New York City. The episode, reported by correspondent Troy Roberts, follows the investigation into what initially appeared to be an accidental overdose but quickly became a suspected…
Worth it if you enjoy classic true crime investigations with clear forensic turning points and don't require deep-dive original reporting.
"Dead Ringer" follows the story of Ramon Sosa, a former professional boxer who owned and operated a fitness gym with his wife, Lulu Sosa. When their marriage deteriorated, Ramon became concerned that he might be targeted in a murder-for-hire plot orchestrated by his wife or associates. Rather than waiting passively,…
Worth it if you enjoy police sting operations, marital crime narratives, and Peter Van Sant's investigative reporting style.
This 48 Hours episode examines the murder trial of Dr. Tomasz Kosowski, a plastic surgeon accused of killing attorney Steven Cozzi. The case centers on a missing lawyer and the evidence prosecutors presented to secure Kosowski's conviction, including a 'murder bag' and a paralyzing agent. Correspondent Erin Moriarty…
Worth it if you enjoy courtroom drama with unusual twists (self-represented defendant) and want a concise overview of a high-stakes murder conviction.
This 48 Hours episode explores the often-overlooked psychological and social burden carried by family members of convicted murderers. Rather than focusing on the crimes themselves, the episode centers on the relatives left to grapple with guilt, shame, and public stigma. The episode features three compelling case…
Worth it if you're interested in true crime from a psychological or sociological angle, or if you appreciate investigative journalism that humanizes overlooked perspectives in criminal cases.
This 48 Hours episode, originally aired in 2009 and rebroadcast in 2026, covers the 2003 discovery of an unidentified teenage girl's remains found stuffed in a bag behind a restaurant. The core investigative thread centers on the use of forensic facial reconstruction—a sculptor created a detailed face reconstruction…
Worth it if you're interested in forensic science applications in criminal investigation and cases where innovative techniques lead to victim identification.